Smiley Cookie Oatmeal Raisin Cookies Review

ByJanel
114 Comments

Smiley Cookie offers fresh sugar cookie treats that are delivered across the country. Their signature cookie is a round smiley face but this cookie is also available shaped as a smiley jack-o-lantern, heart, flower, and more!

You can even create your own custom cookies with their cookie designer that lets you pick the cookie shape, frosting color, and smiley frosting color. In addition to sugar cookies, Smiley Cookie also offers chocolate chip and oatmeal raisin cookies.

These Smiley Cookies make the perfect gift for your child’s new teacher as they head back to school this year or a fun lunch box treat to remind your child to be happy and enjoy their day!

Smiley Cookie Review

We were able to sample a variety of Smiley Cookies including their Original Smiley cookies, mini smiley cookies, oatmeal raisin, and chocolate chip. The cookies are not made with preservatives but you can freeze them and pull out the batch when you’re ready to use them.

Since we got all the cookies at once, I put the mini smiley cookies right into the freezer so we wouldn’t gobble up all of the cookies right away. My boys couldn’t wait to try the original large Smiley Cookies! They thought they were so much fun and they were yummy too.

They weren’t as soft as I had hoped they would be, but you can cook them for just a few seconds to soften up the cookie and frosting as suggested the directions that came with the box. We enjoyed the chocolate chip cookies also but they seemed pretty ordinary.

Smiley Cookie Review

The Gourmet Oatmeal Raisin cookies were absolutely amazing! I’m not one that usually loves oatmeal raisin cookies. I will eat them, but they are among the bottom of my usual picks when I have a variety to choose from. However, when I tried the Oatmeal Raisin cookies made by Smiley Cookie they were seriously so incredibly good that I couldn’t STOP eating them!

My brother was over when I pulled them out and between the two of us, we finished off over half the bag in one sitting. We both couldn’t stop saying over and over how delicious they were and he even commented that they were his “new favorite cookie” and I totally agree!

They were most and flavorful and so incredibly good! I can’t speak highly enough of them!! When we’d finished off all the cookies I pulled out the bag of mini smiley cookies I had stashed in the freezer.

I was really curious to see if they would be hard or stale since they had been frozen. I tried out the microwave trick and microwaved 3-4 at a time since the mini’s are much smaller than the original smiley cookie. They came out of the microwave so soft and moist and really good that the mini smiley cookies were my second favorites. My boys loved picking out what smiley color they wanted and this bag didn’t last long either as they were very yummy!

Smiley Cookies are available at www.smileycookie.com and start at just $14.99 per dozen.

Disclosure: I received a variety of Smiley Cookie samples in exchange for my honest review. I was not compensated in any other manner. The opinions expressed above are my own and any claims should be verified on the sponsor’s site.


More Posts

  • Sears Optical Review & Back-to-School Special


    Sears Optical has had over 50 years in the eye care industry, and are experts in family eye care. 聽They have experienced opticians to help you with all your glasses and contact needs, including an eye exam. 聽They have great brands and a large selection of frames, too….


  • Rolfs Salon Review – Check out my Makeover!!


    Rolfs Salon is a high quality salon with professional stylists and an atmosphere that you will love! They offer services for hair, skin, makeup, and even waxing and bridal services. I love the quote found on the mirror at my seat at Rolfs Salon which really demonstrates the…


  • The Great Mouse Detective available now on Blu-ray!


    The Great Mouse Detective Available for the first time on Blu-Ray and HD Digital When the diabolical Professor Ratigan kidnaps London鈥檚 master toymaker, the brilliant Basil of Baker Street and his trusted sidekick Dawson try to elude the ultimate trap and foil the perfect crime. This family classic…


  • Toddler Fashion: Freshly Picked


    I received Freshly Picked Moccasins in exchange for this post. All opinions are my own. By now you have probably seen cute moccasins on the feet of babes all around you. You have probably seen or heard about Susan Peterson, or maybe you just saw her on Shark…


  • Shaker Bench Review


    I received a Shaker Bench in exchange for my review. All opinions are my own.聽 Do you have a problem you need solved? My problem is ALWAYS organization! We bought our home 8 years ago before we had a single kid, and now our home is bustling with…


  • World’s Best Fudge Recipe


    What brings your family closer together? For me, my family enjoys bonding over games and treats. After a long day of work, there’s nothing more relaxing and rejuvenating than family game night. Because there are only 2 adults and a toddler in my family, my husband and I…


114 Comments

  1. I would choose heart-shaped cookie with pink icing for the base and red icing for the smile!

    tridingermckee at gmail dot com

  4. I would choose the star cookie and it in yellow icing with a pink face color.
    lauraemerson17 at yahoo dot com

  9. I would choose the original smiley with white as the base and pink for the smiley face!

  27. I’d pick the Mini Smiley with yellow base icing and and red smiley face. These are adorable and would brighten anyone’s day ! Love it!

  40. I would pick the yellow star cookies for Carter as he just loves stars! I would pick the yellow frosting and the orange face on the star! So cute

  54. I’d do a heart with purple and yellow frosting.聽 Thanks.
    partymix25(at)hotmail(dot)com

  61. 聽Smiling Faces Gift Basket – Gourmet Sugar Cookies and Mug

    Smiling Faces Gift Basket – Gourmet Sugar Cookies and Mug

  71. i would have the heart cookie, with pink icing and a purple smiley face color (jennifer reda)

  74. I have to go with the classic round, pink base and white smiley face color. 聽That’s the way the cookies we got from the bakery looked when I was a kid, and you can’t beat nostalgia.

  82. I’d like the Original in yellow with red eyes and smile.
    Thanks so much.
    rickpeggysmith(at)aol(dot)com

  85. I’d choose the Flower Cookie W/Royal Blue Base Icing and Yellow Smiley Face Icing. These are so cute! I’d love to have something like this when my daughter gets married next yr. Thanks for the yummy giveaway!

  87. I’d pick a flower cookie with pink icing and black smiley face! 聽So neat.

  96. I would like the traditional Smiley, round with yellow frosting and black writing.

  98. Visit Smiley Cookie and leave a comment telling me what your custom smiley cookie would look like!

    Flower shaped cookie

  110. My custom cookie would be the heart with purple icing and a pink smile!聽 Thanks.

Comments are closed.